Synergic effect of exogenous lactate and caffeine on fat oxidation and hepatic glycogen concentration in resting rats
Article information
Abstract
[Purpose]
Although several physiological roles of lactate have been revealed in the last decades, its effects on energy metabolism and substrate oxidation remain unknown. Therefore, we investigated the effects of lactate on the energy metabolism of resting rats.
[Methods]
Male rats were divided into control (Con; distilled water), caffeine (Caf; 10 mg/kg), L-lactate (Lac; 2 g/kg), and lactate-plus-caffeine (Lac+Caf; 2 g/ kg + 10 mg) groups. Following oral administration of supplements, resting energy expenditure (study 1), biochemical blood parameters, and mRNA expression involved in energy metabolism in the soleus muscle were measured at different time points within 120 minutes of administration (study 2). Moreover, glycogen level and Pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH) activity were measured.
[Results]
Groups did not differ in total energy expenditure throughout the 6 hour post-treatment evaluation. Within the first 4 hours, the Lac and Lac+Caf groups showed higher fat oxidation rates than the Con group (p<0.05). Lactate treatment decreased blood free fatty acid levels (p<0.05) and increased the mRNA expression of fatty acid translocase (FAT/CD36) (p<0.05) and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma coactivator 1-alpha (PGC-1α) (p<0.05) in the skeletal muscle. Hepatic glycogen level in the Lac+Caf group was significantly increased (p<0.05). Moreover, after 30 and 120 minutes, PDH activity was significantly higher in lactate-supplemented groups compared to Con group (p<0.05).
[Conclusion]
Our findings showed that Lac+Caf enhanced fat metabolism in the whole body and skeletal muscle while increasing hepatic glycogen concentration and PDH activity. This indicates Lac+Caf can be used as a potential post-workout supplement.
INTRODUCTION
Lactate has been regarded as a waste product of anaerobic glycolysis (e.g., during high-intensity exercise), and because of its acidic nature, has often been viewed as a potential cause of muscle fatigue during exercise [1,2]. However, lactate production occurs naturally regardless of oxygen concentration in our body. Moreover, the lactate acidosis paradigm has been drastically reconsidered, as it is currently known that lactate is not responsible for acidosis. Instead, acidosis associated with exercise has been argued to be induced by increased H+ production from ATP hydrolysis [3]. Based on the lactate shuttle theory, lactate can be produced and transported to adjacent organs, where it is oxidized. During exercise of any intensity, the energy for muscular contraction is also provided by lactate.
Motivated by the novel physiological roles of lactate, researchers have investigated the effects of exogenous lactate administration on muscle. For example, lactate administration upregulates peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma coactivator 1-alpha (PGC-1α) mRNA, which is related to mitochondrial biogenesis in the muscle [4]. Moreover, a cell-based approach revealed that lactate supplementation increases satellite cell activity and anabolic signals in C2C12 cells [5]. In rats, administration of a lactate-based supplement associated with low-intensity exercise elevates the number of myonuclei, indicating that lactate effectively promotes the development of muscle mass [5]. Furthermore, lactate is used as fuel much faster and to a greater extent than glucose, when ingested in sports drinks [6]. Nevertheless, it is still unknown how exogenous lactate is metabolized with time and how it affects energy substrate utilization. Notably, these previous studies used lactate-based supplements, which actually contain lactate and caffeine. Hashimoto et al. [7] reported that sodium lactate and caffeine treatment followed by voluntary wheel running for 5 weeks lowered the scapular fat weight relative to that of the exercise group, along with lower body weight than that of the sedentary group. Concurrently, proteins, including comparative gene identification (CGI)-58 and hormone sensitive lipase (HSL), were higher in the lactate- and caffeine-treated groups than in the sedentary group. However, previous studies have not elucidated the metabolic effects of lactate or caffeine. Therefore, an investigation of the metabolic effects of lactate alone and in combination with other substances is needed [8]. Moreover, our laboratory previously studied the effect of lactate administration in terms of glycogen synthesis and demonstrated that glycogen synthesis enzymes such as pyruvate carboxylase and glycogen synthase 2, increased following treatment with the same dosage of lactate [9]. In this context, the glycogen levels and specific mechanism based upon previous findings require further investigation.
The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of lactate on energy metabolism and energy substrate utilization in rats. This effect was compared to that of caffeine and a mixture of lactate and caffeine, as caffeine is commonly used as a positive control in these types of studies due to the promotion of fat oxidation, energy expenditure [10-13], and exogenous carbohydrate oxidation during exercise [14]. We hypothesized that lactate can significantly increase fat oxidation and exert a synergistic effect with caffeine, which might enhance fat metabolism-related mRNAs. Thus, we hypothesized that lactate administration can enhance hepatic glycogen concentration.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals
Male Sprague-Dawley rats (7 weeks old) were housed in standard plastic cages under controlled relative humidity (50 %) and temperature (23 ± 1°C) conditions, with alternating 12 hours of light (07:00–19:00) and dark (19:00–07:00) cycles [15,16]. The experiments were performed during the 12 hours light cycle. Rats were fed ad libitum with a commercial normal diet. This study was conducted in accordance with the ethical guidelines of the Konkuk Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (KU16018, KU18137).
Experimental procedure
We performed two studies referred to as study 1 and study 2 (n = 32 per study; Figure 1). In study 1, rats were divided into control (Con; distilled water, n = 8), caffeine (Caf; 10 mg/kg, n = 8), L-lactate (Lac; 2 g/kg, n = 8), and lactate-plus-caffeine (Lac+Caf; 10 mg + 2 g/kg, n = 8) groups for both studies. Rats were starved for 2 hours prior to administration. The resting metabolic rate (RMR) was recorded using indirect calorimetry for 6 hours after the treatment. In study 2, the same number of rats were assigned to each group such as control (Con; distilled water, n = 8), caffeine (Caf; 10 mg/kg, n = 8), L-lactate (Lac; 2 g/kg, n = 8), and lactate-plus-caffeine (Lac+Caf; 2 g/kg + 10 mg, n = 8). Rats were starved for 2 hours prior to administration. Then rats were euthanized via cervical vertebral dislocation at different time intervals (0, 30, 60, and 120 minutes) after oral administration of treatments. Subsequently, skeletal muscle (soleus muscle), liver, and blood samples were obtained, frozen in liquid nitrogen, and stored at –80 °C until analysis of mRNA levels and biochemical parameters. The soleus muscle is selected for mRNA analysis due to its oxidative characteristics. The dosages for treatments were based on those used in previous studies [17,18], and treatments were orally administered. In a previous study, 3 g/kg of lactate was intraperitoneally injected to set the blood lactate levels at approximately 20 mmol/L, which are similar to those attained upon maximal exercise 18 . However, this study aimed to examine the basic effect of lactate on metabolism. Therefore, we selected a lower stimulant dose and a previously reported administration method.
Indirect calorimetry
To examine the effect of lactate on energy substrate utilization in the whole body, we measured the RMR for 6 hours after treatment using an open circuit calorimetric chamber (model RL-600, Alco System, Chiba, Japan). This equipment is known for its accuracy and is widely used for calculating gas exchange data [19,20]. We measured the RMR as previously described [21-23].
Blood parameters and mRNA expression analyses
Blood samples were obtained from the pulmonary artery using a syringe and stored in EDTA tubes for centrifugation. The resultant plasma samples were then analyzed for lactate, glucose, free fatty acids (FFA), and glycerol levels using commercial kits (Lactate Colorimetric/Fluorometric Assay kit, Biovision; Glucose Colorimetric Detection Kit, Arbor Assays; Free Fatty Acid Assay Kit. Cell biolabs; Glycerol Colorimetric Assay kit, Cayman chemical). For mRNA analyses, we extracted RNA from the soleus muscle and analyzed it by reverse transcriptase PCR method. The soleus muscle was selected for analysis as we did not have any other treatment except for supplementation. Additionally, we believed that the soleus muscle would be the most appropriate tissue to study the metabolic changes. Commercial kits were used for cDNA synthesis and amplification (amfiRivert cDNA Synthesis Platinum Mater Mix, R5600, Gendepot, USA, amfiEco Taq DNA Polymerase, P0701, Gendepot). We measured the mRNA expression of glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH), fatty acid translocase (FAT/CD36), carnitine palmitoyltransferase 1b (CPT1b), PGC-1α, and pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase 4 (PDK4). The expression levels of these genes were normalized to that of GAPDH. The sequences of primers used for PCR are listed in Table 1.
Glycogen analysis
Glycogen levels were measured from 30 mg of gastrocnemius muscle and 30 mg of liver, respectively. Using the amyloglucosidase method [24], we added 500 uL of 2 N HCL to these specimens and incubated the mixtures on a heating block for 2 hours at 96 °C. During the 2 hours of incubation, the tubes were tapped every 30 minutes to ensure proper digestion. After 2 hours of incubation, 1500 uL of 0.67 M NaOH was added and centrifuged for 5 minutes at 5000 x g, at 4 °C. The supernatant was mixed with reaction buffer and incubated for 30 minutes at room temperature. The glucose content was analyzed using a spectrophotometer (Thermo Fisher scientific, USA) at 340 nm.
Pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH) activity analysis
PDH activity was measured from liver tissue samples using the PDH Activity Colorimetric Assay Kit (Biovision, Mountain View, CA, USA). According to the instructions, we used BioVision’s Mitochondria Isolation Kit (K288-50) to isolate mitochondria from the tissue. The PDH activity was determined using 10 mg of liver sample. The colorimetric measurement of the kinetic reduction of NAD+ to NADH was conducted for 60 minutes at 450 nm.
Statistical analysis
Data are presented as mean ± standard error (SE). In study 1, statistical significance was evaluated using two-way repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) for respiratory gas exchange data and one-way ANOVA for the 2 hours sum of respiratory gas exchange data. In study 2, one-way ANOVA was used to determine the changes in mRNA levels and blood parameter concentrations, and Bonferroni post-hoc analysis was conducted if significance was reached. Differences were considered significant at P < 0.05. Differences between the groups for the analysis of glycogen were determined by independent sample t-test. For statistical analysis of PDH activity, we used two-way repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA), and one-way ANOVA between the groups in the same time period. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. PDH
RESULTS
Respiratory gas exchange
In study 1, we measured the RMR for 6 hours in each group, whereby we calculated energy expenditure, fat and carbohydrate oxidation, and respiratory exchange ratio. Energy expenditure did not differ significantly among groups throughout the measurement period (Figure 2a). Moreover, the accumulated energy expenditure within 2 hours intervals did not differ significantly (Figure 2b).
The rates of fat oxidation were higher in the Lac and Lac+Caf groups than in the Con group throughout the 6 hours measurement (Figure 3a). Furthermore, animals in the Lac and Lac+Caf groups showed significantly higher fat oxidation in the first 4 hours post-administration than those in the Con group (p<0.05) (Figure 3b). Interestingly, when the global rate of fat oxidation was analyzed in relation to the total time of measurement (6 h), only the Lac+Caf group presented higher fat oxidation rates than those of the Con group (Figure 4). As expected, an opposite trend was observed for carbohydrate oxidation (Figure 5a), which was lower in the first 2 hours post-administration in the Lac+Caf group than in the Con group (p<0.05) (Figure 5b).
Blood parameters
Plasma lactate levels were higher in the Lac, Caf, and Lac+Caf groups than in the Con group during the first 60 minutes after treatments (p<0.05) (Table 2). At 120 minute, there were no significant differences between groups. Moreover, no significant changes were observed in plasma glucose levels at any sampling time (Table 2). In contrast, we found significant differences in FFA levels between groups at all sampling times (p<0.05) (Table 2). Lactate administration, as either Lac or Lac+Caf, significantly lowered FFA levels relative to those of the Con group at 30 minute (p<0.05). In that regard, the co-administration of caffeine and lactate resulted in lower levels of FFA than those in animals treated with lactate alone. This pattern changed at 60 minute, when FFA levels were higher in the Lac and Lac+Caf groups than in the Con group (p<0.05), and higher levels of FFA were noted in caffeine-treated animals (Caf and Lac+Caf) than in animals that received only lactate (p<0.05). After 120 minutes, the only significant difference in FFA levels was between the Con and Lac groups, wherein animals treated with lactate had lower FFA concentrations than Con animals (p<0.05). In the case of glycerol, the Caf group showed significantly higher plasma levels than the Con and Lac groups 30 minutes after the treatments (p<0.05) (Table 2). Furthermore, the Caf group presented the highest glycerol level at 60 minute (p<0.05), whereas no changes were observed between groups at 120 minute.
mRNA expression analysis
The transcript levels of FAT/CD36 did not differ significantly during the first 30 minutes (Figure 6a). However, at 60 minute, the Lac group had significantly higher FAT/CD36 mRNA levels than the Lac+Caf group (p<0.05) (Figure 6a). Moreover, the Lac group presented higher FAT/CD36 mRNA expression than the Con and Caf groups after 120 minutes (p<0.05) (Figure 6a). No changes were observed in CPT1b mRNA levels among groups (Figure 6b). In the case of PGC-1α expression, mRNA levels were higher in the Lac group than in the Caf and Lac+Caf groups at 30 minute (p<0.05) (Figure 6c). The same trend was observed for PDK4 mRNA, whose levels were higher in the Lac group than in the Caf and Lac+Caf groups at 30 minute (p<0.05) (Figure 6d).
Glycogen concentration analysis
We examined the glycogen concentration following treatment with supplements. Lac and Lac+Caf were selected based on previous results. Either of the treatments was administered to each group to examine the changes in glycogen levels. The glycogen concentration did not show significant changes following lactate administration (Figure 7-a,c). However, following treatment with Lac+Caf, the concentration of glycogen was significantly increased (p<0.05) (Figure 7-d).
PDH activity analysis
The PDH activity level was measured following the administration of each supplement at timepoint (0, 30, 60, and 120 minutes) (Figure 8). Interestingly, the Lac+Caf and Lac group maintained significantly higher PDH activity for the entire 120 minutes following administration compared to the Con group (p<0.05). The Lac and Lac+Caf groups showed significantly higher levels compared to Caf at the 30- and 120-minute time point as well (p<0.05)–highlighting the effect of lactate-based supplements on PDH activity.
DISCUSSION
In this study, we aimed to investigate the effect of exogenous lactate and a lactate-based supplement on energy metabolism and energy substrate utilization in resting rats. We assessed whole-body energy metabolism in study 1 and further conducted gene expression analysis and blood parameter assessment in study 2. The parameters for gene expression and blood analysis were determined based on the results of study 1.
The most interesting findings were those related to energy metabolism in the whole body of animals. We could not detect significant differences in total energy expenditure rates between the groups. The lack of changes may be related to our experimental design of an acute single bout of supplement, which may not be enough to affect whole energy expenditure. Nevertheless, this protocol was enough to significantly affect fat oxidation. We found that fat oxi-dation increased in response to the acute Lac and Lac+Caf treatments in the first 4 hours after administration. Although not statistically significant, fat oxidation rates in the Lac and Lac+Caf groups tended to be higher than those in animals that received caffeine alone in the initial 4 h. These results are concurrent with previous findings on the combinatorial effects of lactate and caffeine. Chronic caffeine intake is known to reduce body fat levels [7]. Therefore, we could not determine whether fat reduction after combinatorial caffeine and lactate treatment resulted from the synergic effect of both supplements or the individual effects of caffeine and lactate. Moreover, in a previous study, the ingestion of caffeine increased the metabolic rate by 0.2 kJ/min and this increase lasted for 3 hours in healthy male volunteers [12]. Similar results were also reported in resting rats, where their O2 uptake was significantly higher (P < 0.05) 2 hours after the administration of 10 mg of caffeine than that of the control [13]. In our study, we detected differences in fat oxidation for a longer period (4 h) after the acute administration of lactate and lactate-plus-caffeine. Moreover, when the fat oxidation data during the 6 hours were combined, we found that the Lac+Caf group had significantly higher fat oxidation rate than the Con group. Considering that caffeine alone did not cause significant changes in fat oxidation, lactate alone can be regarded as a remarkable supplement that induces fat oxidation in vivo. Indeed, mice treated for 14 days with lactate injections (2 g/kg) showed 4 % weight loss [25]. Overall, our results indicate that not only lactate, but also lactate-plus-caffeine, may have positive effects on fat oxidation. The mechanisms by which lactate and lactate-plus-caffeine exert their effects require elucidation.
To explore the biochemical and molecular mechanisms underlying the effects of exogenous lactate administration, we assessed selected mRNAs in muscle samples and biochemical parameters in blood. Based on our acute experimental design, we determined that mRNA analysis would be more appropriate than protein analysis. We found that two transcripts associated with energy metabolism, FAT/CD36 and PGC-1α, were affected by lactate treatment. FAT/CD36 plays an important role in transporting fatty acids, while PGC-1α is the main regulator of mitochondrial biogenesis. Other functions of PGC-1α include regulation of the metabolic rate [26], control of mitochondrial gene expression [27], and modulation of many genes related to energy homeostasis and mitochondrial biology [28,29]. Our observations are consistent with those of previous studies, in which PGC-1α levels increased in L6 cells (isolated from rat skeletal muscle) after 6 hours of lactate treatment (10 and 20 mM) [4,30]. Interestingly, lactate, which is regarded as a harmful byproduct of glycolysis, induces the expression of PGC-1α. Lactate has been recently reported to be strongly associated with transforming growth factor-beta 2 (TGF-β2), which improves glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity, increases fatty acid uptake and oxidation, and stimulates glucose uptake in the skeletal muscle, heart, and brown adipose tissue [31]. These effects of TGF-β2 may have stimulated fat metabolism herein. Similarly, numerous proteins enhancing fat metabolism may have been stimulated upon lactate treatment. Therefore, the expression of other proteins needs to be analyzed after chronic lactate administration at an optimized dose. Previous studies have used protocols involving the injection of lactate into animals or the incubation of cells with lactate. However, we administered lactate orally, which is a more convenient and less invasive route of administration. Nevertheless, our results are consistent with those of studies using other routes, indicating that this approach may be used to further investigate the role of exogenous lactate, including its specific mechanisms and effects of chronic treatment. Furthermore, the analysis of protein levels may also shed some light on the underlying mechanism of action. Additionally, our understanding of the results of blood parameter analysis is limited. Caffeine increased fat oxidation-enhanced lipolysis, such that FFA levels were increased in 60 minutes, while lactate did not cause drastic alteration in FFA levels compared to Con treatment. However, gas exchange analysis showed that lactate increased fat oxidation in the whole body. Therefore, the effect of lactate on blood and whole-body parameters requires more supportive data from studies involving chronic lactate treatment to elucidate the underlying mechanism.
Considering the other applications of lactate, based on respiratory gas exchange data and mRNA analysis, we could detect an imbalance between carbohydrate and fat oxidation, in which carbohydrate oxidation was inhibited and fat oxidation was enhanced. These results were confirmed via microarray analysis (data not shown) by the presence of several enzymes such as phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase 1 (PCK1) and acetyl-CoA acetyltransferase 2 (acat2) which has a role in carbohydrate and lipid metabolism, respectively. Moreover, we demonstrated an increase in hepatic glycogen level via a single bout of Lac+Caf administration. Likewise, in mice, the chronic administration of 2.5 mg/g lactate for 3 weeks after a bout of treadmill exercise increased glycogen concentration in the white muscle when compared to mice treated with saline [32]. Moreover, lactate incubation with C2C12 cells (mouse muscle cells) increased the follistatin protein level and phosphorylation of P70S6K, which are anabolic signals and critical regulators of exercise-induced muscle protein synthesis and hypertrophy [5]. These observations imply that post-exercise lactate administration could be effectively used to optimize muscular anabolic signals and glycogen restoration, which may have important implications in the training context (e.g., for athletes). Furthermore, the PDH activity was enhanced following the administration of lactate-based supplements. In this regard, lactate enhances both glycogen synthesis and glycolysis regulated by PDH activity. From previous research [33,34], upregulated PDHa activity by exercise was examined concomitant with elevated plasma FFA levels. Moreover, elevated FFA levels are also associated with enhanced PDK 4 expression [35,36]. In the current study, the whole-body gas results confirmed the increase in fat oxidation with the administration of Lac+Caf. Therefore, based on the previous studies, metabolic changes in enhancing fat oxidation may induce PDK4 and PDH activity similar to when exposed to exercise, resulting in increased hepatic glycogen concentration. Based on these findings, the research for determining optimizing timing for lactate supplementation on sparing circulating carbohydrate and glycogen reserves. Moreover, further research is required to study the effect of Lac+Caf with different component ratios on glycogenesis and fat oxidation. This may potentially improve the management of individualized supplementation on individuals’ purpose of either glycogen synthesis or fat oxidation or different component ratio based on supplementation timings. Lastly, another possible application of lactate is for the treatment of sedentary people. Albeit no significance in energy expenditure, we demonstrated a single bout of lactate administration enhanced fat oxidation. Therefore, our results suggest that chronic lactate intake potentially enhances fat oxidation, thus potentially leading to body fat loss, even in sedentary individuals. Furthermore, our findings indicate that the combination of low-intensity exercise, which is not burdensome to sedentary individuals, and regular dietary control with lactate treatment could exert more significant effects on weight reduction.
Of note, as the purpose of our study was to examine the fundamental effect of lactate supplementation and lactate-based supplements compared to that of control and caffeine treatment, the design of our study involved an acute treatment. Moreover, we considered the practical future application of lactate and decided to administer the supplements orally to mimic the eventual administration route in humans (e.g., drinkable supplements). Therefore, even though we considered the changes among groups in whole-body parameters with P < 0.05 as significant, it is possible that the treatments in the present study were not enough to affect the gene expression and blood parameters.
In conclusion, we found that exogenous lactate orally administered to resting rats increased their fat oxidation rates. The induction of fat oxidation was associated with changes in mRNA levels of key genes involved in lipid metabolism and circulating levels of FFA. Lactate treatment showed remarkable effect on the induction of fat oxidation, thus providing novel insights into the metabolic effects of lactate treatment. Moreover, when ingested with caffeine, lactate also showed sparing effect of glycogen which may elicit huge advantages in athletes. Further research, including the assessment of long periods of treatment, may reveal additional details on the specific mechanisms underlying the metabolic effects of exogenous lactate.
Our current study has a limitation. As lactate administration or infusion is known to induce alkalosis which inhibits carbon dioxide ventilation [37-40], the respiratory exchange ratio could have been misrepresented. Thus, the isotope method could be considered to revise this calculation. However, in the current study, there was no significant difference within groups in terms of oxygen uptake and carbon dioxide production (data not shown). Moreover, the mRNA results show some metabolic changes to be favorable to fat oxidation. Therefore, from the current study—besides alkalosis— lactate administration seems to enhance fat oxidation in the whole body.
Acknowledgements
Choongsung Yoo and Jisu Kim contributed equally to this work. The authors would like to show their gratitude to the Exercise Nutrition Laboratory at Konkuk University for their cooperation in this study. This work was supported by the Ministry of Education of the Republic of Korea and the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF- 2019S1A5A8033825). This research was supported by the KU Research Professor Program of Konkuk University.